The Science Survey

Pennsylvania Redraws Gerrymandered Districts

%E2%80%9CWhether+in+your+favor+or+not%2C+gerrymandering+is+wrong+and+undemocratic%2C%E2%80%9D+said+David+Lipkin+%E2%80%9918.
“Whether in your favor or not, gerrymandering is wrong and undemocratic,” said David Lipkin ’18.

“Whether in your favor or not, gerrymandering is wrong and undemocratic,” said David Lipkin ’18.

Matilda Melkonian

Matilda Melkonian

“Whether in your favor or not, gerrymandering is wrong and undemocratic,” said David Lipkin ’18.

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






In anticipation of the 2018 midterm elections, the Supreme Court voted on February 5, 2018, that Pennsylvania’s highest court ruling, requiring lawmakers to redraw the state’s congressional district map, would stand. Pennsylvania originally had until February 15th to draw their new map.

The case was first brought to the Supreme Court by Pennsylvania Republicans when the state Supreme Court found the extremely partisan congressional districts to go against the state constitution, as they were favoring the Republican party. As cited from their constitution, “elections shall be free and equal,” and the overly gerrymandered districts do not ensure an equal election.

Gerrymandering is the manipulation of lines dividing congressional districts to favor one party versus another. Two methods of gerrymandering are ‘cracking’ and ‘packing’; either cracking up districts so that, for example, there are not enough Democrats in any district so that they do not win that area, or packing all the Democrats into one district so that they only win one or two districts out of, for example, fifteen. “In gerrymandering, there is always clear favoritism. In Pennsylvania’s case, there was no question that the lines were unfair,” said Aliana Sheers ’18.

With the previous Pennsylvania map, thirteen of Pennsylvania’s eighteen seats in the House of Representatives were Republican. An increasingly nonpartisan map could possibly help Democrats regain the House, making three seats lean more Democratic, and less Republican.

On February 13, 2018, two days before Pennsylvania’s deadline, their governor, Tom Wolf, vetoed the redrawn map put forth, claiming that it was still gerrymandered. As published in The New York Times, President Trump was upset with the Supreme Court’s decision to even reconsider the map in the first place, stating that the redrawn map was “unfair to Republicans and our country.”

“Whether in your favor or not, gerrymandering is wrong and undemocratic,” said David Lipkin ’18.

Currently, Republican lawmakers have filed a federal lawsuit against Pennsylvania, saying that the state went against its constitutional authority when it discarded the old map and proposed a new one. They now are aiming for the impeachment of the five state justices making the decision.

Although this case might be soon settled for Pennsylvania, partisan gerrymandering and its constitutionality is still an issue at hand for several reasons. Gerrymandering can come in many forms, including racial and partisan gerrymandering. This June, the Supreme Court will decide on whether or not gerrymandering goes against the US Constitution. If found unconstitutional, several states will be be forced to redraw their maps prior to the 2020 elections.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Navigate Left
  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    Dr. Richard Hertzberg ’55, Ph.D., Delivered Keynote Address at Bronx Science’s 90th Commencement Ceremony

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    Newly Elected S.O. Board Members Discuss Platforms for 2018-2019

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    Former CIA Operative Suspected Of Disclosing Secret Information

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    New York City’s Drop in Crime Rates

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    The Game of New Horizons

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    Down to the Last Drop

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    Net Neutrality Follow Up

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    Make Room for the Rise of Aldi and Lidl

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    The Women’s March

  • Pennsylvania Redraws  Gerrymandered Districts

    News

    Get Busy with JPROM Committee

Navigate Right
We've got the news down to a science!
Pennsylvania Redraws Gerrymandered Districts